apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


Searching for the Perfect Green Paint Color
Good Questions

2010-01-gqgreenpaint.jpg

Q: I'm looking for the perfect soft green to paint my nursery. I've bought several pieces of furniture from the Stokke line in Natural, and am planning on bright decor- orange, bright blue/turquoise, spring green. I've also bought the "Tales Green" bedding from Stokke. Picking out wall paint makes me sweat- I've had to redo many a paint job in the past, because it turns out differently than I had in mind. I would like a soft green, not too olive-y or gray. Any suggestions?

Sent by Amanda

 
 

Editor: We know what it feels like to stand in front of hundreds of paint chips and feel overwhelmed and confused. Anyone have ideas for paint colors close to what Amanda's described?

• Got a question? Email yours with pic attachments here (those with pics get answered first)

Tags

Good Questions

Share

Comments (35)

I painted a living/dining area in Ralph Lauren's "Turlough Green", which was a nice, understated colour that worked well with my teak furniture. It is nice because it is neither minty nor sagey.

posted by ParisTroika on January 21st 2010 at 1:45pm
view ParisTroika's profile

i don't have a specific color to suggest, but i would suggest getting mini samples and testing them on the wall... we were looking for the perfect shade of green for our living room and they all looked completely different on the wall, and the ones we liked best in our home ended up being the ones we were unsure of in the store... green was a hard color for us to get right!

posted by erinpearce on January 21st 2010 at 1:47pm
view erinpearce's profile

I suggest that you look at Devine Paints. They have a TON of selections (make sure you go to a store that has ALL the options).

I say this because they are the only ones who use the actual paint for their swatches and not digital. So whatever you see on the swatch is EXACTLY what you will get on your wall.

Anything else you are taking a chance. You probably will like it, but still why take chances if you don't have to??

GOOD LUCK!!

posted by Sleek1 on January 21st 2010 at 1:53pm
view Sleek1's profile

Sleek1, doesn't Yolo also use actual paint for their large swatches?

posted by heather77 on January 21st 2010 at 2:01pm
view heather77's profile

I used "Pod" from C2 for my son's room and love it.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lanastewart/3579440548/in/dateposted/

posted by OttawaMom on January 21st 2010 at 3:16pm
view OttawaMom's profile

My baby's room is Honeydew by Sherwin Williams.

It's bright without being obnoxious, soft without any drab undertones.

In general, I highly recommend Sherwin Williams paints. They cover really well, and usually don't require an extra coat. Whatever you choose, stay away from Behr paint! I have had so many bad experiences with that paint that can't be blamed on the color or a bad can.

posted by funnymonkey on January 21st 2010 at 3:19pm
view funnymonkey's profile

I used crocodile tears by Valspar for my living room and loved it. However, I might suggest 'sprout' to you for your nursery. Light, soft and airy but not pastel.

http://www.materials-world.com/paint-colors/valspar_lows_laura_ashley/valspar_lowes_tradition/valspar_lowes_tradition_28.htm

posted by Oven Mitzie on January 21st 2010 at 3:23pm
view Oven Mitzie's profile

I adore Valspar Willow Wind, although from your description it might be a tad on the gray side for you. It's in my daughter's nursery and will also be going in our kitchen as soon as we get around to painting it!

Behr Lion might be worth checking out, too. I've seen it in several friends' homes and think it's very nice. It's a bit warmer than Willow Wind.

Remember, you can have your paint store mix up a color in almost any brand's color. We used Benjamin Moore Natura paint in Willow Wind for the nursery - the BM store already had the color in their computer system so we didn't even need to do a color match with a paint chip.

posted by haleyrs on January 21st 2010 at 3:30pm
view haleyrs's profile

For my daughter's nursery, I used Behr's celery and feldspar and created stripes with the colors. Both those colors can be found on the same paint chip.

http://www.ohdeedoh.com/ohdeedoh/nursery-tours/nursery-tour-sophia-anns-celery-stripes-039823

posted by SVHornickel on January 21st 2010 at 3:38pm
view SVHornickel's profile

Ace Hardware Kindersely

posted by arielle on January 21st 2010 at 4:07pm
view arielle's profile

We used Willow Branch by AFC - I would describe it as a springy green. We have yet to create the rest of my toddler son's room around this accent wall, but after living with it for a few months, I still love the color.

posted by sjh100 on January 21st 2010 at 4:13pm
view sjh100's profile

I'm with erinpearce. Paint samples. Colors can trick even the best "colorists." Different parts of the country, different weather, different rooms in the house, different walls in the same room, different times of day....If you've had to re-do paint in the past, maybe it had more to do with tricky conditions than with your abilities. Hopefully, your favorite brand of paint comes in little samples/pots. If not, quarts might be a worthwhile investment. Slap some up and live with it a few days. Have fun!

posted by smellofsawdust on January 21st 2010 at 5:38pm
view smellofsawdust's profile

bring the bedding in to the paint store and they can match the color exactly...that way you know it will go together.

posted by lnp838 on January 21st 2010 at 6:34pm
view lnp838's profile

We went through this "journey" for our child's nursery. We tried matching to fabric and mini-samples. We ended up with B. Moore's Stem Green from their low VOC line...very fresh, bright, but not bold, gender neutral green. We still love it 2 years out!

posted by shenster on January 21st 2010 at 7:21pm
view shenster's profile

Gee, I'd ask the lady whose post is just above this one. LOVE those walls.

posted by 2kidsandus on January 21st 2010 at 8:23pm
view 2kidsandus's profile

2kidsandus - thanks...that's me :) the color is "Rejuvinate" from Behr.

posted by ourcozynest on January 21st 2010 at 8:55pm
view ourcozynest's profile

Benjamin Moore Chameleon. My son's room is this color. It's really soft, not a lime green. More like a pale, soft apple green. You can see a link to it here, along with the Domino spread where I got the idea: http://jackandlila.wordpress.com/2009/08/25/rooms-of-their-own/

posted by adanielo on January 21st 2010 at 8:59pm
view adanielo's profile

We used Behr's grass cloth. Very nice.

posted by sbsterling on January 21st 2010 at 9:00pm
view sbsterling's profile

I would echo funnymonkey's comments - we have had great luck with Sherwin-Williams paints, and esp. love their low VOC options. We used a combo of their Shagreen and Ryegrass in our boys' room and I love the colors.

posted by abby1116 on January 22nd 2010 at 7:28am
view abby1116's profile

I love Farrow and Ball's "cooking apple green".

http://www.farrow-ball.com/productdetails.aspx?pid=0032CG&cid=PC&language=en-GB

posted by eando on January 22nd 2010 at 7:49am
view eando's profile

Get yourself a sample pot of DKC-45, and try it.

http://www.coxpaint.com/store/cart.php?target=product&product_id=18855&category_id=255

Trust me on this -- it is an amazing colour!

It changes colour based on the light -- in bright light, it can look almost yellow, other times it looks most decidedly green (because it is a full spectrum paint composed of many more pigments than regular paint -- which is also why it is more expensive than regular paint). It glows!!! It is very cheerful, bright, and happy. It will match everything you have. We painted our toddler nursery back home with this colour, and it was everyone's favourite bedroom because of the colour and the feeling it gave the room!

posted by mschatelaine on January 22nd 2010 at 8:19am
view mschatelaine's profile

Donald Kaufman, Farrow & Ball, and many others also use real paint on their swatches; Devine paints are not the only ones. Generally, the brands which charge for colour cards use real paint, as it is more costly to make them.

posted by mschatelaine on January 22nd 2010 at 8:21am
view mschatelaine's profile

I second the comment on avoiding Behr paint -- we had a HUGE problem with a Behr primer we bought (last time we ever try to economize on *that* item!). The primer didn't stick to the drywall compound, causing the upper coats of paint to peel off where ever there was primer underneath. We had a technical analysis done to see if it was the drywall compound or the primer; it was the primer. We took the problem to Behr, and they did nothing. They don't stand behind their products.

We also made the mistake of using them on our deck, and it failed after 2 winters -- it all peeled off. We only use Benjamin Moore, Pratt & Lambert, Farrow & Ball or Fine Paints of Europe now.

posted by mschatelaine on January 22nd 2010 at 8:27am
view mschatelaine's profile

i always use behr paint and have never had any issues at all. with or without primer.

posted by ourcozynest on January 22nd 2010 at 11:04am
view ourcozynest's profile

We haven't had any issues with Behr paint either.

posted by heather77 on January 22nd 2010 at 11:16am
view heather77's profile

I painted my son's room in Dynasty Celadon from Behr. I liked it so much I used the same color for the whole downstairs.

posted by sarahez on January 22nd 2010 at 1:57pm
view sarahez's profile

Not everyone is going to have a problem with the paint, but it is curious that in these forums, the "problem paint" that keeps coming up is always the same, always Behr...

After what happened to us, we realized that the most costly part of any paint job is the labour -- be it in dollars or be it in time -- and so we now gladly pay more for reliable paint.

posted by mschatelaine on January 22nd 2010 at 2:35pm
view mschatelaine's profile

Sherwin Williams "Harmony" line is zero VOC, covers beautifully, and is often on sale for only $22/can. After using Benjamin Moore for years, I've now switched to SW Harmony... I just have them mix the Ben Moore colors :)

Benjamin Moore's "Grecian Green" is a nice soft green. It's a Pottery Barn color, too. It's fairly neutral, though.

posted by honeyhaze on January 22nd 2010 at 9:22pm
view honeyhaze's profile

Our kitchen and family room is Leap Frog green by Sherwin Williams. I love it so much even after 5 years. It looks great with so many colors. Such a bright, happy color.
Not the best picture...only one I had on hand but you can see the color behind the bookcase.
http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4044/4296860794_cd09deff8f_b.jpg

posted by piperlemons on January 22nd 2010 at 9:27pm
view piperlemons's profile

We recently painted a nursery green, and love the outcome, but it was harder to pick the right green than I thought! I was trying to match a color in some fabric, and picked out 5 colors that I thought we should try, and got sample pots (small size containers, perfect for a trial square on the wall) from our local Benjamin Moore dealer. None of them were even close, some were hideous! We went to pick a couple more and on a whim I showed the woman at the store what I was trying to match, she VERY quickly pulled out 2 sample chips (way larger than the color cards we were working from) and said how about these? She was dead on right!

So my advice is, if you are trying to match something, take it with you to the paint store and ask them for help! They know color, and they know what will feel warm, bright, shocking, etc.

posted by kathleen08 on January 23rd 2010 at 4:00pm
view kathleen08's profile

We used "Citrus Twist" by Mythic Paint Co. for our daughter's nursery. It was cheerful but subtle, minty but not too fresh. Everybody who walked in the door loved it.

posted by mergirl on January 25th 2010 at 12:54pm
view mergirl's profile

Since it hasn't been mentioned, we went with Rainforest Dew in my daughter's room. But the person who says "different parts of the country, different weather, different rooms in the house, different walls in the same room, different times of day...." is very true. Our first house was a east/south east facing room in Texas and our current room is a east facing room in Seattle and boy.....it looks different. I couldn't find a link to our rooms; but it is a very nice pale green (although might be on the yellow side) and works nicely with blue and pink which are the accent colors my daughter has selected over the years.

posted by PNWGal on January 25th 2010 at 1:34pm
view PNWGal's profile

BTW Rainforest Dew is a Benjamin Moore color.

posted by PNWGal on January 25th 2010 at 1:35pm
view PNWGal's profile

Another trick is to find the spring green color you are using at the bottom of the paint chip, then paint the walls one of the pale versions of that color -- usually one of the top three colors on the sample chip.

I did this once with a Benjamin Moore olive green that matched a lampshade in the room, and got a fantastic taupe-y-moss-cream shade on the wall that went great with every color in the apartment (red, blue, olive, brown, etc.).

Sadly, Benjamin Moore subsequently reconfigured some of their sample cards to range from gray to green. But they still make the traditional colors. You can find them at any store that carries the full range, such as Janovic in NYC, which owns Benjamin Moore (or vice versa).

Farrow & Ball isn't too big on yellow-greens, but check them out because if they do have a color you like, the paints are all very soft and receding because they are natural and they are also low VOC.

Paint Library might also have something.

I agree you must always test everything in your own environment, and also that Benjamin Moore and Farrow & Ball are very high quality, and Behr is to be avoided. Their paints are cheap and the colors have a greyish cast. Very unattractive.

posted by mopar on February 4th 2010 at 11:25am
view mopar's profile

Martha Stewart also has a ton of soft greens, but I have never actually tried the paints.

posted by mopar on February 4th 2010 at 11:26am
view mopar's profile