apartment therapy changing the world, one room at a time


In Defense of the Play Date
Slate.com

2009-08-playdate.jpg

Besides a few casual meetups in the park, we haven't made any official play dates for our son so we've yet to wade into these potentially treacherous waters. Ideally we imagine a play date in which our son and a mate enjoy themselves playing peacefully together whilst we share in some adult conversation with a friendly, similarly-minded parent. But from what we hear and read, play dates can be fraught with tension, judgment, and misunderstandings.

 
 

So we were interested to read a recent article, "In Defense of the Play Date," by Emily Bazelon on Slate. She starts by recounting Mary McCarthy's depiction of a catty, condemnatory play date in The Group which, frankly, put chills down our spine. While admitting to a few play date "mishaps and mismatches" Bazelon proceeds more optimistically to talk about the positive experiences and relationships she's made through play dates.

What about you - do play dates help you keep your sanity or push you over the edge?

Tags

Parenting

Share

Comments (12)

My 1.5 year old son and I go to a play date almost every morning. We belong to a mom's group that thankfully is mostly catty-free and open-minded. Of course we get along with some moms and kids better than others and of course it's hard to keep opinions to ourselves at times, but we do the best we can and genuinely enjoy each other's company. I would go stark raving madd without these wonderful women in my life.

I think it's harder to do it when you're not part of group. There's so much social pressure, and of course the thought of putting time into a relationship that might ultimately fizzle out or not meet expectations is daunting. I've found that within a group, people come and go and relationships are struck over time and familiarity. There's no one way of doing things, but for me as an introvert my mom's group has been an incredible resource.

posted by Oven Mitzie on August 3rd 2009 at 12:49pm
view Oven Mitzie's profile

I made a bunch of new mom friends after having my first son, and coincidentally, we all had our second children at about the same time three years later. We get together at each others' houses - sometimes in small groups, sometimes en masse - and we've all agreed to never EVER refer to our get-togethers as "play dates". :)

posted by TammyE on August 3rd 2009 at 12:50pm
view TammyE's profile

i think that casual meet-ups at park are the perfect speed for young children. you and/or your child will know when you've come across someone that you'd like to open your home (and life) too. its a big step and one that should feel natural and comfortable. if it doesn't, then don't. your children can sense all of that stuff and THAT is what I think makes for awkward and difficult playdates.

posted by aneelee on August 3rd 2009 at 12:59pm
view aneelee's profile

i read that article this weekend and the whole thing was sort of shocking to me...i've never had such an experience with a playdate! maybe my daughter is too young and so all of our play dates are with friends, or maybe i'm just lucky. the whole article was a little nerve wracking about what the future holds...

j
http://prudentadviceformybabydaughter.blogspot.com

posted by jaime5 on August 3rd 2009 at 2:01pm
view jaime5's profile

i guess if i were new to an area or didn't have any friends with kids nearby i would try a mom's group or more random playdates, because getting together with another mom to drink a latte, chat and let the kids burn off some energy together is critical to my happiness... but i have to admit that i am not the kind of person that is interested in "mom groups" or spending time getting to know new people at this point. in fact, it sounds like torture (for me, i'm sure my daughter would love it). i am lucky to have some great like-minded friends around with kids the same age as my daughter (and son-to-be).

posted by katid on August 3rd 2009 at 3:00pm
view katid's profile

I joined a moms group when my husband and I moved to L.A. from Hawaii. L.A. was such a HUGE place that after we had our son, I needed to make some new friends that had kids! My son is now two and I've been hanging out with a group of gals since our kids were about 4 months old and I can tell you now, I don't know how I would have survived being a new mom in a new big city without them! I'm lucky to have not been in a catty situation yet within the group, but that might be why we've gravitated towards each other....we're not those kinds of women. If you feel like you're being preached to, or getting the catty-vibe, just move on to another group....eventually you'll find your match! It really does help you keep your sanity, though, when you have others to talk to that are in the same boat as yourself and it's a great, nurturing, playful environment for your kids too!!

posted by kaleo on August 3rd 2009 at 4:43pm
view kaleo's profile

Who is that gorgeous woman on the left? She doesn't look old enough to be that baby's mom. Must be his babysitter.

posted by mmkohio on August 3rd 2009 at 7:57pm
view mmkohio's profile

I too have had a great experience joining a moms club. They get a bad rap, but I think when you join when your kids our newborns, when moms are their most needy and open-minded, you can form good friendships. It's not always perfect, but it beats sitting at home alone with your child.

posted by badmamajama on August 3rd 2009 at 9:22pm
view badmamajama's profile

I have a mixed experience, it can feel like high school all over again. A lot of competing parenting philosophy... but it sure helps with the isolation of maternity leave for those lucky enough to get it!

If you really want to know playground politics just ask nannies and pre-school teachers.

posted by mariel76 on August 4th 2009 at 11:53am
view mariel76's profile

that is terrifying! thank goodness for minnesota-nice.

posted by doubledutch on August 6th 2009 at 1:56pm
view doubledutch's profile

"Who is that gorgeous woman on the left? She doesn't look old enough to be that baby's mom. Must be his babysitter."

i don't get it . . . are you the gorgeous woman on the left? i don't see why she couldn't be a mother.

posted by doubledutch on August 6th 2009 at 1:58pm
view doubledutch's profile

I don't know how one would survive the toddler years without playdates. I'm not a super social person-- more of an introvert-- but I would have gone nuts if my sole daily interaction would have been with my toddler.

Before I had a kid, most of my friends were artists like me. Thanks to the mommy-world , I have a lot of diverse friends from playdates, mom groups and other mom meet-ups. It's been challenging for me, but I've learned helpful parenting skills and met dear friends.

Sure, the downside is that you might end up spending an awkward morning with a mom that you don't have much in common with. But is that actually THAT horrible? What are people so scared of? Shake off the high school insecurities and get out there.

posted by TheReignofEllen on August 8th 2009 at 8:21am
view TheReignofEllen's profile