
It's time to order the crib...Becky + Andrew want to hear from you. Here's the situation:
Becky says:
Okay – now we really need to order a crib. I love the Oeuf. Not only does it look great (clean lines for our small space), but it is low enough to the ground that I can easily lean over the side. And the woman at Dawn Price Baby in DC where we went to look at it (Dawn Price herself, I think) was so nice and helpful that we would love to give her the business. But, it’s expensive ($824). So, we also thought about getting a Jenny Lind-style crib at a fraction of the price ($219). Although it is far more traditional, maybe it can be modernized with accessories and other furniture in the room.
Answer the survey below the jump...

Andrew says:
$824 for a crib? Oeuf. The sound you make when you’re punched in the gut. I think the Wee-Tot would be just as happy with a trip to Target or a visit to Ms. Lind. Not just because I generally prefer the traditional to the modern, but because we can apply the money saved to far more important purchases, like Redskins and Nationals merchandise for newborns. Nevertheless, for our tight space, I think the modern Oeuf fits better. In fact, while I’m on the topic, some traditional baby furniture is nothing more than a gross caricature of traditional styles. Much of it is so chock full of curly-ques and flowers and spindles that it looks like it was designed by some wayward Victorian who fell out of a Bronte novel rather than someone who actually has to use the stuff.
Update: Since we last checked in (Chapter 2), Becky + Andrew ordered the Monte Luca Glider in charcoal. Becky told us the folks at Monte were incredibly nice and helpful. They can't wait to get the glider.
Target also has some pretty basic cribs around $100. We bought the simplicity Aspen, and are very happy with it. There are plenty of simple cribs to be found and if you match the color (wood or painted) I think that is the more important thing anyway.
BTW Target does seem to carry some modern looking cribs, and I think Ikea does too.
view Monika's profile
Ikea, seriously.
The Gulliver crib has nice clean lines, can be positioned low to the ground, and is about $90. Although I don't have an Ikea crib, I have heard very good feedback about it. Also can convert to a toddler bed--bonus!
http://tinyurl.com/ykmxf6
view dollhouse's profile
What about the new modern crib at Wal-mart. Now I know it's Wal-mart, but the crib looks modern without the price-tag that modern furniture typically brings. As a mother of two I say save your money on the crib, and put it towards furniture that can transition from baby to toddler to kid. A great dresser, beautiful art, or whatever.
view squid's profile
I was going to also suggest the modern two-tone crib from Wal-mart, even though I hate the store and boycott. BUT, it has the look, and I have seriously, SERIOUSLY considered breaking my boycott to get the set when I have another baby. It's THAT CUTE. I think it is about $300 each piece.
view exxon23's profile
i seriously love the ouef crib - especially in the walnut. i say if you can swing it - go for it. i also love the look of the toddler bed that it converts to - one of the few that doesn't leave you with one tall crib side to make it look like a cage.
i know i couldn't afford it and will probably go with the gulliver (or the similar looking brio crib if i can find it in the states by the time i have a kid). but the ouef is just so pretty and really makes an impact.
view molly h's profile
There is also another clean-line crib at Target: the Childcraft Shaker ridge crib:
http://www.target.com/gp/detail.html/ref=br_1_13/602-9718624-5489414?ie=UTF8&frombrowse=1&asin=B0009ROBQS
And here is the link to the Walmart modern collection: http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?product_id=5185226&povid=cat86325-env3708-module40684-lLink1
view exxon23's profile
I second IKEA. We have the DIKTAD crib/toddler bed. As a toddler bed, it does not have tall sides. There was a lighter wood one called TASSA I saw in the store that I liked, but don't see online.
view jubgulia's profile
Have you checked out the Argington Sahara crib? It's 685 - still expensive but you save a little money :). And it's really pretty and modern looking.
view EMC14's profile
I third IKEA. I know the urge is great to get a cool crib, but think of all the diapers you can get with what you save. I have a TASSA crib, which is a perfect square, basic, and does the job beautifully. It's maybe 130 bucks and it also can be made into a toddler bed. Not online for some reason, but it's available in stores. Spending 800 dollars on a crib is like getting a 900 dollar bugaboo. i just don't get it. They're all made in China. It's not like some craftsman in Denmark is personally crafting this Oeuf for you.
view evertonpalmer's profile
These suggestions are great! Thanks so much to everyone. I really like that Target crib, Exxon23 -- and I had not seen it. (Had seen the Walmart crib and like it.) Well, we're heading off to IKEA later this week (didn't make it last weekend). We'll let you know what we decide! As for the Argington crib, I love it but decided a while ago that, in our small room and given how clumsy we are, Andrew and I would pummel our shins constantly on that ledge that sticks out! -- Becky
view becky d's profile
We got a Jenny Lind, and after the damage our son visited on it when he was teething I am so, so happy we got a cheap crib. All cribs look like crap once they have teeth marks all over the rails. We put the difference in his college savings account, and ditto what we didn't spend on a bugaboo. (Incidentally that is a stroller I have come to hate after trying to squeeze by them dozens of times in our tiny neighborhood cafe -- it is one super-wide stroller. Now when I see someone with two kids in a Phil&Ted I want to run up and thank them.)
view dot's profile
I also really like the Oeuf but couldn't afford the price, so I made my own. It's an almost identical copy, but I got to be extra choosy about materials--kid friendly finishes, and an extra strip of cherry around the top rail for gnawing on. Here's a bad picture: http://www.flickr.com/photo_zoom.gne?id=471962107&size=m
view Burton's profile
Okay, I'm in the minority here but since Becky and Andrew bought the Monte Luca glider I think they should go with what they love and buy the Oeuf crib. I also loved the Oeuf crib but we ended up getting a lovely crib from a friend. It was too much of a deal to pass up, and we didn't end up spending very much on our nursery. Now that my son's almost two and I see what an energetic little teether he is, I'm glad we didn't spend the big bucks, but in all honsety I would have a hard time spending anywhere near $800 for a glider. If I had a whole heap more money I would have bought the Oeuf.
view reef's profile
We just bought a Jenny Lind though we had been contemplating more design & modern cribs. Frankly it all comes down to how much money you spend & can spend on other things. How much did you pay for your own bedframe and mattress, which you expect to probably use for at least 10 years. Compare that to a crib you will use for a couple years. Should tell you if it is wise to buy a $824 crib.
view joebelt's profile
Burton - that crib is beautiful! i love the extra strip you added, and the changing tray is even more practical with the addition of the handles. great job.
view molly h's profile
Burton - What an amazing crib. I wish I had an ounce of that talent!
view becky d's profile
With such a small space I think it's important to find things you love - whether expensive or not. With that said, if you are planning on having more than one child and using the crib again, the Oeuf crib might be worth the investment. However, you may want to look at other alternatives if you think you will only use the crib for a few years. Maybe Burton could be convinced make another amazing crib?
view cc's profile
dear becky,
like you i lusted after the high-end cribs (oeuf at al) but having only recently finished graduate school and begun working (for pay, that is) i couldn't justify such a high end expenditure on something my son will only be using for two or three years. so my husband and i did buy the jenny lind. not my favorite, to be sure (i tried to get the gulliver at IKEA but found out a few months ago that they are no longer being sold, at least at that time) but it works. we splurged instead on couple of items that will be around much longer--a blu dot modulicious no. 4 dresser doubles perfectly as a changing table and an eames rocker (at half off retail price--a DWR annex score!)--both of which bring me much happiness! remember, at the end of the day, it's just a crib. as long as it's safe, that's what matters. your baby won't sleep better in an $800 vs $100 bed!
view mintyfreshgirl's profile
How long are babies in cribs? 2 years max? And if you convert to a toddler bed, MAYBE 2 more years? I know I have always been overly practical, but the Oeuf, while beautiful, does not seem worth it to me. Buy something cheaper and put the extra money in the college fund.
view fiona's profile
The gulliver at Ikea is the best looking crib with a small footprint we saw under $1000. It has simple clean lines. Much better looking than the Target, Wal-mart, or chain options even at four or five times the price.
The other option was Stokke but at that price, plus the expensive linens, plus the cost of conversion kits, we couldn't justify it.
We really liked the Arlington Sahara but it was too big for our space. Many of the other modern designs were really cheap-looking, especially for the money.
view JudiAU's profile
Becky - I really relate to your choices!
At the time my daughter was born, I wanted either a Netto crib (but balked at the price) or a jenny lind style crib from Plain Jane -- we got the Plain Jane one and had it custom painted bright turquoise. It is very fun, and we love it although now we have moved, it does not suit our nursery as much as the IKEA Gulliver crib.
I have come to the practical conclusion (only because I am on my second child!) that they are in their cribs for such a short time -- maybe 2 years, or 3 with it as the toddler bed (which the Gulliver accomodates), that it is not worth while spending a real fortune. A simple well-made crib with a good mattress is the way to go (we got a natural latex one, which is hypoallergenic). And the IKEA one is very similar to the Oeuf crib (no nice wlanut detailing, I know...).
Spend the extra money on art work or furniture that they will not grow out of...
(you would not have caught me saying this when I was having my first baby!)
view mschatelaine's profile
We purchased the Wallmart "modern" crib. Cream and Brown. We also purchased the toddler rail, so that we can stretch the use of the crib...our son slept in his crib/toddler bed till 4! We also bought the matching bureau (just put the changing mattress on top!) Plus we find many changing tables are low and at 5'7" and 6'4" we appreciated the baby being closer! And then after diapers are gone you have a nice bureau. We switched out the knobs with these cool chunky steel roses!
Good Luck w/ your decision!
view smallhousebiglife's profile